Unpopular Science
Sidenote illustration by Jess DG Hayes for chapter 17, “The Busy Beaver That Ate the TREE”
Sidenote illustration by Jess DG Hayes

Chapter 17 of 50

The Busy Beaver That Ate the TREE

„Das Unendliche hat wie keine andere Fragevon jeher so tief das Gemüt der Menschen bewegt...Aus dem Paradies, das Cantor uns geschaffen,soll uns niemand vertreiben können.“
(“The infinite! No other question has ever moved so profoundly the spirit of man... Cantor’s paradise, from which no one will expel us.”) — David Hilbert, 1926

Imagine you are given a pen with enough ink to write 20 centimeters and you are to write the biggest number you can think of. You can start by a tower of exponents 1010⋯1010^{10^{\cdots^{10}}}, but it is not that big. In this chapter we explore the hierarchy from computable functions to TREE(3) — a number so immense that even if you built a tower of exponentials starting with a trillion raised to the power of a trillion, and then repeated that construction every attosecond for a trillion years, the result would still be vanishingly small in comparison. Yet even TREE(3) sits as close to infinity as the number eight, placing us in an infinity zoo where sizes exceed the categories brains evolved to handle.

Topics

  • Sand Reckoner
  • Tower Notation
  • Knuth Arrows
  • 20cm Ink Competition
  • Ackermann Function
  • TREE(3) Combinatorics
  • Tree Embedding Game
  • Busy Beaver
  • Halting Undecidability
  • Rayo’s Function
  • Large Cardinals

Sidenote

Top (Valid TREE(3) Sequence Prefix): An initial segment of a TREE(3)-avoiding sequence. Each rooted tree is added in such a way that no earlier tree is homeomorphically embeddable into a later one. The sequence starts with simple trees and becomes rapidly more complex. Exponentiating a googolplex by itself a googolplex times is comically dwarfed by TREE(3).

Bottom (Largest Number Competition): Using 20 cm of ink, write the largest number possible. Early entries include exponential towers and Knuth up-arrow notation. But one leverages the TREE function hierarchy in TREE(TREE(3))\text{TREE}(\text{TREE}(3)) — a number vastly larger than previous contenders. The final banner is a different type of entry, more reminiscent of Rayo’s number.

Coming to YouTube

Beyond Popular Science: the films

Each chapter is becoming a short film: the book’s own words, read to camera, with its figures, sources and equations animated alongside.

The films go out under the UK edition’s title, Beyond Popular Science. The fifty chapters are the same in both editions.

Coming soon

Subscribe to the channelYouTube (opens in a new tab)
Front cover of Unpopular Science by David H. Silver: hand-drawn science doodles by Jess DG Hayes around the title

This chapter is one of fifty in Unpopular Science.

For readers curious enough to want the actual mathematics, tired of science communication that oversimplifies or sensationalizes. Science as it actually is: demanding, complex, but well worth the effort.