Unpopular Science
Sidenote illustration by Jess DG Hayes for chapter 39, “Superanonymous”
Sidenote illustration by Jess DG Hayes

Chapter 39 of 50

Superanonymous

“Why should I refuse a good dinnersimply because I don’t understand the digestive processes involved.”
Oliver Heaviside, 1893

A significant combinatorial breakthrough from an unlikely source: an anonymous 4chan post (2011) responding to a question about anime episode viewing orders. Superpermutations are strings containing every possible ordering of n symbols as substrings. For years, mathematicians believed the minimal length followed the pattern of factorial sums observed in small cases. The anonymous poster derived a rigorous lower bound, modeling the problem as path optimization through a permutation graph. This proof remained obscure until 2014 when mathematician Robin Houston rediscovered it, leading to the disproof of the long-standing conjecture and establishing new bounds on this combinatorial problem — with the original derivation still officially credited to “Anonymous 4chan Poster.”

Topics

  • Superpermutation Problem
  • Permutation Overlap
  • Hamiltonian Path Approach
  • Sum-of-Factorials Conjecture
  • n=6 Counterexample
  • Anonymous 4chan Proof
  • Haruhi Anime Origin
  • Robin Houston Discovery
  • Greg Egan Upper Bound
  • Combinatorial Compression
  • Non-Academic Mathematics

Sidenote

Superpermutation over Anime Orders: The sequence 1,2,3,1,2,1,3,2,1 visits all six permutations of {1,2,3}\{1,2,3\} as contiguous subsequences: 123, 231, 312, 213, 132, 321. Here, episode “1” is Dragon Ball Z (Vegeta), “2” is One Piece (Straw Hat Crew), and “3” is Sailor Moon. This is a minimal superpermutation for n=3n=3: the shortest possible viewing order that guarantees every order of watching (back-to-back) all three shows appears.

Coming to YouTube

Beyond Popular Science: the films

Each chapter is becoming a short film: the book’s own words, read to camera, with its figures, sources and equations animated alongside.

The films go out under the UK edition’s title, Beyond Popular Science. The fifty chapters are the same in both editions.

Coming soon

Subscribe to the channelYouTube (opens in a new tab)
Front cover of Unpopular Science by David H. Silver: hand-drawn science doodles by Jess DG Hayes around the title

This chapter is one of fifty in Unpopular Science.

For readers curious enough to want the actual mathematics, tired of science communication that oversimplifies or sensationalizes. Science as it actually is: demanding, complex, but well worth the effort.